In the insurance industry, an “act of God” typically refers to a natural event or disaster caused by forces that are outside of human control. For instance, if lightning strikes your home and sets it on fire, your homeowners insurance would most likely cover the damage. However, many policies exclude certain acts of God, like floods and earthquakes. For those, you would need to get a separate policy.
If your car insurance includes comprehensive coverage, it might also cover natural disasters like falling trees, rockslides, or hail damage. A similar defense can come up after a car crash. If a driver causes an accident through what appears to be reckless driving, they might claim a medical emergency was the reason and that they aren’t responsible.
While that could be a legitimate claim, it does have limits. It also has to be proven. If you’ve been the victim of a car crash where the other driver is claiming a medical emergency or other “act of God” caused it, you need to speak with an experienced Jackson car accident attorney. Your attorney can help investigate the accident to determine who should be held accountable and what you’re entitled to collect.
The Sudden Emergency Defense in Mississippi Car Accidents
Mississippi is an at-fault state for car accidents. This means that the at-fault driver is responsible for the medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and any vehicle property damage. Typically, you will file an insurance claim with that at-fault driver’s insurance carrier.
If a driver claims a medical emergency caused a crash in Mississippi, the situation turns on the sudden medical emergency defense. If the defense holds up, the driver may be found not at fault. That could mean turning to your own insurance, such as medical payments or collision coverage, if you carry it.
To use this defense, the driver must prove the medical event, such as a heart attack, stroke, or seizure, was completely unexpected and happened suddenly while they were driving. If the event truly could not be anticipated, the driver may not be held legally negligent for losing control of the vehicle.
It is important to note that a driver can still be held liable if the driver knew they had a medical condition that made an episode likely, like uncontrolled diabetes or a seizure disorder. They can also be held liable if they ignored early warning signs such as severe dizziness, lightheadedness, or blacking out before getting behind the wheel.
Criteria for a Valid Sudden Medical Emergency Claim
The at-fault driver and their insurance company cannot simply claim a medical emergency. The driver has to prove it, and that usually takes solid medical documentation and evidence. Here are the core criteria courts look for:
- Sudden and Unforeseeable: The medical emergency episode must strike without warning. That means that the driver or party had no prior knowledge, history, or medical advice indicating the event might occur.
- Physical Incapacitation: The event must be a physical medical breakdown such as a heart attack, stroke, seizure, or sudden drop in blood pressure. Additionally, falling asleep at the wheel or getting distracted generally won’t count as a medical emergency.
- Total Loss of Control: The person must experience a complete blackout or be physically unable to operate or steer their car at the exact time of the accident.
- Medical Documentation: Because a blackout is easy to claim and hard to disprove, Mississippi courts expect the driver to present all the evidence available, including medical testimony. Emergency room records, paramedic reports, and a physician’s diagnosis are the usual proof.
Why You Need a Lawyer to Challenge a Medical Defense
You hope you never get involved in an accident, and if you do, you hope it won’t be your fault. If the at-fault driver claims a medical emergency, it can create challenges in pursuing compensation. It can slow everything down. That is why you need an experienced attorney to support your claim.
The attorneys at Pittman, Roberts & Welsh, PLLC can help with this exact type of claim and investigation. This includes reviewing the at-fault driver’s medical history to see whether they ignored prior warning symptoms, violated physician driving restrictions, or failed to manage a known pre-existing condition. Any of those can defeat a medical emergency defense.
We’ll also take over all the communications with the insurance company. We’ll present all relevant evidence to determine who should be held accountable for the accident. If the medical emergency turns out to be genuine and the driver isn’t liable, we can help you figure out what your own policy covers, such as medical payments or collision coverage. Our goal is to help our clients get fair compensation for their injuries.
Call to schedule a free consultation to discuss what happened in the accident. We can answer your questions and talk about what should happen next.